Research

Shifting Paradigms in Greenfield Geothermal Systems

Geothermal developments come with significant risks. Estimating the potential power output of a greenfield system has been a longstanding issue in the industry. Unfortunately traditional resource assessment methods used for making investment decisions have high uncertainty. This body of research aims to address this challenge by introducing a new method of resource assessment that includes more complete data and respects reservoir physics.

Overview

Resource Assessment for Greenfield Geothermal Systems

Challenge

As geothermal has attracted more attention, there is a renewed interest in exploring previously undeveloped (greenfield) geothermal systems. The economic viability of a geothermal development greatly depends on the resource potential. However, estimating the resource potential has high uncertainty due to sparse exploration data, meaning that investment in greenfield systems comes with high levels of risk.   

Traditionally, the potential power output of a greenfield geothermal system has been estimated using stored heat or areal methods. These methods are easy to apply during the early stages of resource development but have significant limitations. The stored heat method relies heavily on unknown parameters, such as the recovery factor, while areal methods rely purely on analogy with existing geothermal developments. Neither approach considers reservoir or wellbore physics and, therefore, can misrepresent the estimated power output of a greenfield resource.

The economic viability of a geothermal development greatly depends on the resource potential.

Solution

Our novel approach to resource assessment combines numerical modelling and uncertainty quantification to help address some of the uncertainties in early-stage geothermal developments. The method uses the same data as traditional stored heat calculations but also includes reservoir physics, wellbore physics and realistic energy extraction scenarios to provide more accurate forecasts of a resource’s potential output. This method leverages cloud computing resources and fast simulation software like Waiwera to run thousands of reservoir simulations in parallel. 

The method begins with developing a conceptual model of the geothermal system based on data from 3G surveys. These surveys provide insights into the geological and structural setting, alteration zone and deep upflow locations. The conceptual model informs the development of the numerical model, which can be continuously updated as more data becomes available. We refer to this workflow as integrated reservoir modelling.  

Greenfield systems are inherently uncertain. We represent this by treating the reservoir model parameters (e.g., deep hot upflows, rock permeability and porosity) as uncertain. Each parameter is assigned a statistical distribution that describes the probability of the parameter taking a given value. We generate an ensemble of reservoir models from these distributions, which are run to their natural state. Each sample model has a different set of reservoir parameters that may (or may not) represent the greenfield system. 

We use approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) to ‘condition’ the ensemble of reservoir models on the location and temperature of the base of the clay cap. This results in a ‘filtered’ set of reservoir models, which match the available exploration data and can be used for forecasting.  

We have developed an innovative production algorithm to forecast the potential power output of a greenfield system. This algorithm implements a realistic extraction scenario that maximises power production from each reservoir model by targeting favourable locations for production and injection wells. This results in a distribution of electrical power outputs, which reflects the uncertainty in the potential of the resource. This offers more realistic estimates than traditional methods as it can represent complex reservoir dynamics.

Graph of resource assessment power output

Our algorithm implements a realistic extraction scenario that maximises power production from each reservoir model by targeting favourable locations for production and injection wells.

Our Team

Photo of Dr John O'Sullivan.

Dr John O’Sullivan

Co-Director

Photo of Professor Mike O'Sullivan

Professor Michael O’Sullivan

Professor

Ken Dekkers

Ken Dekkers

Research Engineer

Michael Gravatt

Dr Michael Gravatt

Senior Lecturer

Ryan Tonkin

Dr Ryan Tonkin

Research Fellow

Ru Nicholson

Dr Ru Nicholson

Senior Lecturer

Oliver Maclaren

Dr Oliver Maclaren

Senior Lecturer

Dr Theo Renaud.

Dr Theo Renaud

Research Fellow

Photo of Rony Nugraha

Rony Nughara

Doctoral Candidate

Photo of Joris Popineau

Joris Popineau

Geothermal Reservoir Engineer

Photo of Joris Popineau

Dr Jeremy Riffault

Research Engineer

Alexander Catalinac

Alexander Catalinac

Research Engineer

Highlighted Papers

2024

O’Sullivan, J., Alia, W., Aloanis, A., Dekkers, K., Fuad, A., Gravatt, M., Nagoro, B., Nugraha, R., Popineau, J., Pratama, A., Rahmansyah, F., Renaud, T., Riffault, J., Takodama, I., Tonkin, R., & O’Sullivan, M. (2024) Towards a New Framework for the Systematic Assessment of Indonesia’s Undeveloped Geothermal Resources. 46th New Zealand Geothermal Workshop, Auckland, New Zealand.

2023

de Beer, A., Gravatt, M., Renaud, T. Nicholson, R., Maclaren, O. J., Dekkers, K., O’Sullivan, J., Power, A., Popineau, J., Riffault, J., & O’Sullivan, M. (2023). Geologically Consistent Prior Parameter Distributions for Uncertainty Quantification of Geothermal Reservoirs. 48th Workshop on Geothermal Reservoir Engineering, Stanford, California.

2023

Nagoro, B. B. R., & O’sullivan, J. (2023). Quantifying Geothermal Resource Potential and Uncertainty Analysis using a Natural State Model of Kotamobagu Geothermal Field in North Sulawesi, Indonesia. 45th New Zealand Geothermal Workshop, Auckland, New Zealand.

2022

Dekkers, K., Gravatt, M., Maclaren, O. J., Nicholson, R., Nugraha, R., O’Sullivan, M., Popineau, J., Riffault, J., & O’Sullivan, J. (2022). Resource Assessment: Estimating the Potential of a Geothermal Reservoir. 47th Workshop on Geothermal Reservoir Engineering, Stanford, California.

Partner with Us

Interested in shaping the future of geothermal energy with us?
We believe in the power of collaboration and look forward to embarking on this journey together. Get in touch and let’s explore how we can work together.

Need help with a project?

Facing a complex challenge? We specialise in developing innovative solutions tailored to fit your project needs. Connect with us to discover how our expertise can help transform your vision into a reality.

Get in touch

Do you have a question or need assistance?
Drop us a line and we'll respond as soon as we can.

Geothermal Institute
Level 3, 70 Symonds Street, 
Grafton, Auckland, New Zealand
geothermal@auckland.ac.nz